plavix vs warfarin cost price of cialis michiga grifulvin v 500 mg tab cialis lowest price usa where to buy viagra in patong boots chemists dispensing viagra metronidazole flagyl 500 mg tablet what is it for citalopram 5 mg tablets prednisone life in the body cialis 200 mg what is it cost of proscar much does benicar cost without insurance amoxicillin tqeovertoz for sale motrin ib safe during pregnancy orlistat fda safety when will micardis go generic in the u.s. seroquel xr 100 mg nebenwirkungen isotretinoina 30 mg pre best time start metformin glimepiride medication best price can you cut a cialis pill in half prednisone 100 mg for 5 days cephalexin side effects in elderly costco clopidogrel price thu?c ketoconazole 200 mg viagra in manchester uk effect of nifedipine in pregnancy can fluoxetine be bought over the counter where to get finasteride uk metronidazole vaginal gel oder online with insurance orlistat japan sale what is in naproxen 500mg sildenafil pfizer 50 mg preis is there a generic neurontin s adalat papers in plos one face simon pope m thom list of indian made viagra artane auto centre dublin diamox generic side effects how does propecia work in women ventolin 200 mg clomid como deve ser usado zovirax cream tube size where to buy in malaysia bet limits in linezolid api does walmart sell metronidazole over the counter fluconazole 50 mg alcohol ketoconazole treatment in dogs can viagra be purchased at cvs cialis one day 5 mg prezzo whe to buy cialis in florida i wanna buy viagra in sydney price of cialis 5mg in dubai clomid 50mg generic how to take cialis 20 mg for best results female viagra pill for sale priligy price ireland misoprostol prix maroc skelaxin 800 mg vs. flexeril 10mg allegra 24 sailboat for sale ventolin buy uk ibuprofen 400 mg virkning lioresal 25 mg novartis show that had the viagra sales men prozac 60 mg bupropion hcl sr 75 mg ndc for dexamethasone 10 mg azithromycin 500 mg pille xalatan eye drops price uk propecia europe cephalexin 500 mg 5 days ldn naltrexone buy wellbutrin post traumatic stress disorder walmart pricing of allegra d what is the total cost of metronidazole 400mg how much tretinoin 05 cream reviews how can i buy prednisone. without a rx cialis 20 mg and cialis 50 mg does prozac work eating disorders minocycline h 100 mg cap teva prozac 10 mg libido cetirizine hcl 5 mg chewable what will 1000 mg of naproxen do que es la ciprofloxacina y para que se usa bactrim for ear infection in dogs terbinafine hydrochloride 1 cream 30g price paroxetine costco comprar viagra en quito price of generic evista publix lipitor price direct buy viagra in lahore pakistan kamagra in new zealand doxycycline hyclate oral tablet 100 mg information motrin safe in breastfeeding cialis super active review mobicom papers matei zaharia low cost carrier best site propecia furosemide iv 40 mg how much ibuprofen is in one tablet doxycycline and next day delivery paypal can buy viagra online uk how to take 500 mg metformin twice daily for pcos is flomax sold over the counter clomid 100 mg for 7 days irbesartan winthrop 150 mg pret flomax valves india face really red from accutane can i take two 20mg nexium instead of one 40 mg how safe is benadryl for toddlers depakote safe while breastfeeding indomethacin 50 mg pregnancy erythromycin ointment for conjunctivitis in dogs cost of ventolin in usa cialis 5mg pills in chennai tamoxifen tablets brands in india dutasteride 0 1 mg cyproheptadine syrup buy online where can i buy chewable dramamine is a 100 mg of sertraline alot prednisone 5 mg to 0 online flomax does metronidazole have codeine in it adidas torsion allegra x solebox for sale how much does atrovent inhaler cost effexor tablets canada comprar viagra temuco etodolac 400 mg dosing how long does zoloft stay in your body viagra spres in sri lanka mefloquine in southeast asia 5 htp with seroquel and klonopin safe terbinafine teva 10 mg best side effects free homeopathic viagra is magnesium safe with warfarin can you use clotrimazole in early pregnancy spironolactone reviews for women over 40 albuterol walmart 4 preço cialis generico brasil purchase lopressor viagra in warsaw naproxen tablets i.p.250 mg pa reciprocal states withholding albuterol in dialysis patients hytrin in women clarithromycin 500 mg uti prevacid 24 hour over the counter preis für levitra 10 mg best viagra tablets in chennai atorvastatin side effects 40 mg fluvoxamine prix role of estradiol in ovulation problemas usar cialis costco generic lipitor 80 mg cost actos juridicos de la union europea cephalexin is safe for g6pd allegra mg options lisinopril 5 mg dosis what does ibuprofen 800 mg do to you is flovent a generic drug zofran vs promethazine in the elderly seroquel yearly sales pills viagra with mastercard can amlodipine besylate 10 mg be dosed bid medicament actonel 75 mg depakote 125 mg sprinkle capsule betamethasone in lactation furosemide 40 mg tab price where can i buy bactrim oral for guinea pigs ciprobay xr 500 mg dosage vardenafil nasal spray in india where to buy in bangkok cialis ciprofloxacin hcl 250 mg side effects for dog where to buy viagra in sao paulo cialis viagra mastercard accepted viagra two in one day prometrium buy canada how long valtrex stay in your system buy cialis cheap uk side effects of propranolol in infants can you buy viagra at shoppers drug mart canada will viagra available generic drug amoxicillin cost australia side effects labetalol 200 mg what is pravachol 20 mg brunette model in new viagra commercial nifedipine er side effects in the elderly viagra sale dc is it ok to cut bystolic in half tegretol xr 100 mg cost of brand name synthroid levaquin safe during pregnancy abilify for borderline personality ciproxin 500 mg bronchite how long azithromycin stays in system prednisone 20 mg how often gor eyes cephalexin 500 mg and breastfeeding loratadine user reviews n you take a 150 mg dose of viagra thuoc zestoretic 10 mg puedo tomar 100 mg de viagra orlistat 120mg australia price how to buy viagra generic stardust artane dublin levaquin 500 mg generic name why take pantoprazole first thing in the morning was kostet kamagra in thailand order doxycycline from india best use of tretinoin lialda mesalamine cost il viagra lo vendono in farmacia brand viagra sildenafil citrate doxycycline 100mg sale effect of motilium in pregnancy famvir 250 mg tablets what will happen when i take 20 mg of levitra reducing citalopram from 30 to 25 mg benzac 2.5 australia dexamethasone for intravitreal injection viagra super active low price exelon in philadelphia pa azithromycin ofloxacin combination brands evista costco is there a generic estradiol vaginal cream is coreg safe while breastfeeding acyclovir 400 mg for vertigo is levitra is safe how much does voltaren gel 1 cost nexium tabletas 40 mg does cvs have anything like viagra over the counter metoprolol safety considerations authorized generic montelukast chemist direct sildenafil 100mg seroquel reviews cialis generika 60mg kaufen why does coumadin cause blood in urine buy prevacid in canada buy fluconazole pills phenergan 50 mg suppository price of nexium with insurance can i take my dogs cephalexin 500 mg crestor prix suisse ibuprofen 800 mg sustained release viagra safe with clonidine amoxicillin for pets online valtrex order canada que es clomid 50 mg buy oral ivermectin humans kutub dapoxetine review inderal 40 mg ecuador buying cymbalta cheap buy albuterol inhaler paypal cardizem cd reviews avapro 75 mgs review cialis viagra india can prednisone tablet 50 mg be split 8 pills azithromycin 250 mg viagra online cheap pills allopurinol 100 mg beipackzettel facts about generic cialis use of zofran in pregnancy use of medroxyprogesterone in copd cialis generic .50 cents or less per pill do you have to be 18 to buy benadryl in california how long does it take for amoxicillin 875 mg to work differin cream acne reviews anafranil 25 mg et grossesse risperdal per cosa si usa migraine specialist in nashville tn imuran side effects in canines reviews of naproxen where canbi buy viagra a socialist manifesto author real name venlafaxine 300 mg side effects mobicom outlets in nairobi competitor brand of losartan potassium pain in legs after taking cialis what is abilify used for in teens is prevacid over the counter or prescription fluoxetine hcl 80 mg viagra 25 mg einnahme identify duloxetine hcl dr 20 mg cap purchase abilify guercmorteo voveran emulgel india actos procesales del juzgador tamoxifen bone density premenopausal prix du medicament cialis what is cataflam 50 mg used for is it safe to take 1000 mg of methocarbamol glucophage online order edad puedo usar viagra diflucan 150 mg india atorvastatina 20 mg. mk viagra price australia how effective is 25 mg of viagra how much does a box of claritin cost antibiotiques bactrim et eusaprim how much acetaminophen in percocet 10 levofloxacin pregnancy safety 40 mg. prednisone for 7 days. how long in my system abilify approved health canada price of 200mg kamagra tablet ofloxacin 400 mg united states metoprolol actavis 200 mg woman in fiat viagra commercial simvastatin 40 mg zuzahlungsfrei 150 mg zoloft too much where buy xenical in london thuoc ondansetron 4 mg naproxen 500 mg vs diclofenac 75mg can i bring viagra to the usa azithromycin al 250 mg beipackzettel anafranil 75 mg wirkung albuterol pump cost prix de priligy au maroc where to buy levitra in south africa vibramycin whartisthebestin dosage como devo usar o remedio clomid how to get off cymbalta safely by james harper difference between generic and brand propecia finasteride prix maroc misoprostol como se usa aborto prozac online shop venlafaxine er good reviews when will generic abilify hit the shelves estradiol retencion liquidos safe dosage misoprostol simvastatin 20 mg effetti collaterali betamethasone cream where to buy acyclovir zovirax price in pesos best price on estradiol patch illegal buy viagra line price of cialis daily use enalapril dogs reviews cardizem 300 mg cd capsule safe take nifedipine while breastfeeding brand name drug atenolol generic form cephalexin esidrex 25 mg hydrochlorothiazide what is a generic proventil neb for xopenex nitroglycerin in tachycardia lisinopril reviews side effects musule cramps where is viagra found in abu dhabi vardenafil 20 mg pfizer best time day take zoloft breastfeeding metronidazole 400 mg buy online uk cialis online without prescription that ships fed x how many mg of azithromycin is used to treat chlamydia best generic viagra sites use of erythromycin eye ointment in newborns were buy viagra uk buy cytotec in australia is soma in the same class as robaxin theophylline side effects in humans amlodipine valsartan 5 160 mg tab tor buy finasteride uae azithromycin cost in the philippines atarax price uk best way to get high on gabapentin viagra street price usa baclofen merck nm 10 mg where can i buy generics of micardis in philippines over the counter prednisolone acetate lasix furosemide generic name exelon patch 5 4 6 mg adesivo is levothroid a generic drug mumbai viagra where to buy cost of warfarin at costco real indication for albuterol nebulizer treatment singulair 5 mg dose cost of levitra at walgreen pharmacy prednisone dose pack 10 mg 6 days price for ofloxacin prize of viagra pfizer in pakistan generic for actoplus how long does it take for clomid 100 mg to kick in 100 mg isotretinoin bactrim ds cost walgreens best time to take spironolactone price of zantac mesalamine liquid what manufacturer.of metformin does costco use viagra generic expensive side effects toprol 100 mg order cialis dergboadre comprara cialis linezolid iv price levaquin tendon rupture lawsuit in ohio propecia tablets in india buy viagra cialis tretinoin cream .25 reviews hydrochlorothiazide pill over counter misoprostol como se usa via oral escitalopram 0.5 mg benefits aik banka provera stanja irbesartan tablets 150 mg get off lexapro safely adverse effects of prednisone in rheumatoid arthritis mens pills for viagra dr on the terrace in nz buy metronidazole injectable levonorgestrel 0.75 mg peru how much does bactrim script cost at walmart doxycycline monohydrate 25 mg for cats by weight cat costa o capsule viagra pret ultram 50 mg ibuprofen mobicom papers online algorithm interactivity tretinoin products over the counter montelukast nombre generico cialis generika indien rash in ebv after amoxicillin voltaren gel si può usare in gravidanza buying azithromycin in mexico clonidine hcl 0.1 mg for adhd causing anger can you overdose on escitalopram 10 mg socialist labor party hall size in square miles is maxolon safe in first trimester burn scar specialists in 90065 omeprazole buy india flagyl for dogs without prescription in united states ibuprofen 400 mg nl generic effexor weight gain doxycycline hyclate 100 mg for skin infection acyclovir ointment 400 mg cost without insurance synthroid ab rated generic viagra generico do paraguai gemfibrozil 200 mg ibuprofen uk dose how long does enalapril stay in your system bystolic indications in europe side effects of robaxin in horses how long can naproxen stay in your system blood in urine in lisinopril que es ciprofloxacino ratiopharm 500 mg buy viagra generic 50mg coumadin clinic in charlotte nc sildenafil tablets ip 100 mg recreational warfarin use in ckd ivermectin use in scabies que actos procesales se realizan en la etapa intermedia how long does it take zyrtec to work in cats singulair 10 mg da sueno terbinafine order online brand names of sildenafil in india pharmacy to buy viagra montelukast sodium 4 mg xenical mfg price premarin buyt wihout a prescription prednisone dosage in dogs for arthritis rui nolvadex review voltaren europe labetalol safe while breastfeeding erythromycin 250 mg throat infection valsartan online no prescription images of 100 mg viagra is there a generic cialis on the us market mobic vs motrin 800 mg viagra 25 mg enough for multiple orgasm where to buy xenical in kenya lamisil equivalent uk risperdal filmtabletten 1 mg wirkung is pravastatin safer than simvastatin propranolol sale uk harga zithromax 500 mg where to buy viagra in switzaland zovirax in mercury captopril brand name in pakistan price of flagyl 400mg in pakistan lamisil ultra vs. lotrimin best for rash baclofen liquid concentration safety of us with viagra and aspirin 75mg zyprexa safe dosage anxiety reviews on cialis 10mg voltaren retard 100 mg alcohol fluconazole in dmso for nail fungus warfarin history discovery acyclovir pill cost why is lamisil no longer sold in us cheap vardenafil online paxil stay in system long term effects of mirtazapine in cats airon 10 mg montelukast engorda comprar propecia espa?a orlistat 120 mg 60 caps can buy viagra prague yahoo answers azathioprine safety and toxicity does prednisone cause increase in blood sugar azithromycin brand names in egypt dose adjustment of ofloxacin in renal failure diflucan 150 mg effetti indesiderati much does aggrenox cost obat apa atarax 25 mg donde puedo comprar sildenafil en quito buy cialis mallorca where to which cialis is best daily cpt code for 4 mg decadron arava drug price aciclovir actavis 400 mg generic viagra cheap shipping role of thyroxine in humans usare solo finasteride amlodipine besylate 5 mg per tablet cefdinir cost walmart

Release date: Dec. 22, 2003

Issue date: 1/6/04


Invitation to September 11

By Kenneth R. Timmerman

For more, read "A Marine 'Peacekeeper's' Story," below.


The spider holes where terrorists and the nation-states who back them hide from public view lie in the murkiest recesses of the murky world of intelligence. Rarely do victims of terrorist attacks get to face their attacker, let alone know his identity, especially when the attacker is a foreign government. Individual terrorists such as Osama bin Laden or Ilich Ramirez Sanchez (aka "Carlos the Jackal") - who openly boast of their evil deeds and thus can be tracked, targeted and eventually taken out - are the exception, not the rule.

Or so said the conventional wisdom until a recent groundbreaking public trial in a federal courtroom in Washington that blew the lid off the world's most elusive terrorist sponsor: the Islamic Republic of Iran. That legal action was brought by the families of the 241 U.S. Marines who were killed when terrorists crashed an explosives-filled truck into their barracks near the Beirut airport on Oct. 23, 1983. It raises disturbing questions concerning some of our most basic assumptions about the war on terror.

New intelligence revealed at the March 2003 trial, and independently confirmed by Insight with top military commanders and intelligence officials who had access to it at the time, shows that the U.S. government knew beyond any reasonable doubt who carried out the bombing of the Marine barracks 20 years ago and yet did nothing to punish the perpetrators. Even more disturbing is the revelation, which Insight also confirmed independently, that intelligence then available and known within the government gave clear forewarning of the attack. But this warning never was transmitted to operations officers on the ground who could have done something to prevent or reduce the impact of the devastating assault.

Among the intelligence information initially uncovered by Thomas Fortune Fay, an attorney for the families of the victims, was a National Security Agency (NSA) intercept of a message sent from Iranian intelligence headquarters in Tehran to Hojjat ol-eslam Ali Akbar Mohtashemi, the Iranian ambassador in Damascus. As it was paraphrased by presiding U.S. District Court Judge Royce C. Lamberth, "The message directed the Iranian ambassador to contact Hussein Musawi, the leader of the terrorist group Islamic Amal, and to instruct him ... 'to take a spectacular action against the United States Marines.'"

Rear Adm. James "Ace" Lyons was deputy chief of naval operations for plans, policy and operation at the time and remembers well when he first learned of the NSA intercept. It was exactly two days after terrorists had driven a truck laden with military explosives into the fortified Marine barracks complex just outside the Beirut airport and detonated it, producing the largest, non-nuclear explosion in history, the equivalent to 20,000 pounds of TNT. "The director of naval intelligence carried the transcript to me in a locked briefcase," he tells Insight. "He gave it to me, to the chief of naval operations, and to the secretary of the Navy all in the same day."

At trial, Lyons described the general contents of the message. In a personal tribute to the slain Marines and their families, he had obtained a copy of the NSA transcript and presented it in a sealed envelope to the court. "If ever there was a 24-karat gold document, this was it," Lyons said, "This was not something from the third cousin of the fourth wife of Muhammad the taxicab driver." Lamberth accepted the still-classified NSA intercept into evidence under seal to protect NSA sources and methods. It was the first time in nearly a dozen cases brought against the government of Iran by victims of terrorism that material evidence emanating directly from the U.S. intelligence community was brought forward in such a direct manner.

The existence of this intercept - just one of thousands of messages incriminating the governments of Iran, Syria and Saddam Hussein's Iraq (among others) in deadly terrorist crimes against Americans - long has been rumored. Insight reported in May 2001 on similar electronic intelligence that unequivocally revealed how Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) leader Yasser Arafat personally ordered Palestinian terrorists to murder U.S. diplomats Cleo Noel and George Curtis Moore after a PLO commando took them hostage in Khartoum, Sudan, in March 1973 [see "Arafat Murdered U.S. Diplomats," June 25, 2001].

Then as now, the release of such information shocks many Americans who find it hard to believe that the U.S. government could have had such clear-cut indications of impending terrorist acts and done nothing to stop them or to punish those responsible. And yet that is precisely what the intelligence indicates. And the reasons, far from some dire government conspiracy, appear to be the laziness and incompetence of intelligence officials and bureaucratic gatekeepers who failed to pass on information to the political appointees or Cabinet officers making the decisions.

The message from Tehran ordering Iranian-backed terrorists to attack the U.S. Marines in Beirut was picked up "on or about Sept. 26, 1983," Lamberth said, noting it was nearly four full weeks before the actual bombing. With all that lead time, why did no one take steps to protect the Marines or to head off the attack? "That's a question I've been waiting 20 years for someone to ask," Lyons tells this magazine.

Insight has learned that the CIA station in Damascus received a copy of the terrorist message almost as soon as it was intercepted and transmitted it back to CIA headquarters in Langley, Va. "The response I heard back from headquarters was, 'The Marines? We don't want to know about the Marines,'" a former CIA officer who saw the intercept and was involved in transmitting it to his superiors tells Insight.

Marine Col. Tim Geraghty, commander of the 24th Marine Amphibious Unit then stationed at the Beirut Airport, tells Insight that he never received a warning or even a report based on the message, although he was well aware that his Marines had become "sitting ducks" to hostile militias on the ground. "Generally, yes, we knew the problem," he said, "but we never received anything specific."

This was not because the CIA was stonewalling him, Geraghty believes. "I became personal friends with Bill Buckley, who was CIA station chief in Beirut, and he was giving me everything he had. But we never got a warning mentioning a possible attack on the barracks or mentioning Iran." And yet, as Geraghty himself learned at the trial, such warnings indeed had been picked up and they were very specific indeed.

For one thing, there was no other place but the barracks near the airport where a "spectacular operation" could have been carried out. It was the only major Marine bivouac in all of Lebanon. And then, there was the mention in the intercept of Hussein Musawi by name and the group he then headed, Islamic Amal - a precursor of what later became known as Hezbollah. Both were under direct Iranian-government control. But as former CIA officer Robert Baer tells Insight, in this case the warning "did not mention a specific time or place and so was not considered [by CIA managers] to be actionable." Because of this, the warning never was sent on to Beirut, where Buckley could have passed it on to Geraghty. Until 9/11 such a lack of specificity was a standard excuse.

Michael Ledeen, author of The War Against the Terror Masters, was working as a consultant to the Department of Defense at the time of the bombing. The failure to share intelligence "drove a change in the structure of the intelligence community," he said at trial, "because what they found was that we should have seen it coming, we had enough information so that we should have seen it coming [but] we didn't because of the compartmentalization of the various pieces of the intelligence community. So the people who listen to things weren't talking to the people who looked at things weren't talking to people who analyzed things and so on." That failure, he said, led CIA director William Casey to establish the Counter-Terrorism Center, a new, cross-discipline unit whose sole purpose was to prevent terrorism and, when that failed, to fight back against terrorists.

After the Beirut attack the intelligence on Iran's involvement all of a sudden looked different. And yet, despite evidence that Ledeen categorized as "absolutely convincing," the Reagan administration not only didn't fight back, but within three months of the attack secretary of defense Caspar Weinberger ordered the Marines to leave Beirut altogether, opening the United States to accusations that it had "cut and run" and inviting terrorists to have at Americans with impunity.

Exactly why that happened is still a mystery to many of the participants, Insight discovered in interviews with Weinberger, former Navy secretary John F. Lehman, former deputy chief of naval operations Lyons, Geraghty, former CIA officer Robert Baer and others. To Baer, a self-avowed "foot soldier" in the war on terror, "The information we had on the Iranians in 1983 was infinitely better than anything we had on Saddam Hussein." The failure to retaliate for the attack "was all politics."

For example, the CIA managed to identify the Hezbollah operative who built the bomb in the truck. "His name was Ibrahim Safa. He was working with the Pasdaran - the Iranian Revolutionary Guards - out of the southern suburbs of Beirut," Baer tells Insight. "In the hierarchy of things, he was just a thug who'd found God. He'd been a bang-bang man in the civil war in the 1970s who knew explosives."

One option available to military planners was to target the actual planners of the operation, such as Safa, but that was rejected because of the congressional ban on assassination. "Assassination was forbidden, so we couldn't target individuals, the heads of Hezbollah," Ledeen recalls. "We would have had to go after Hezbollah training camps and kill a lot of innocent civilians." That was something Weinberger says neither he nor the president wanted to do.

Soon the primary target became the Sheikh Abdallah barracks in Baalbek, the capital of Lebanon's Bekaa Valley. A former Lebanese-army barracks, it had been taken over by Iran's Pasdaran and was being used to train Hezbollah and house Iranian troops stationed in Lebanon. "We had the planes loaded and ready to take out the group," says Lyons, referring to Hezbollah and their Iranian masters in Baalbek, "but we couldn't get the go-ahead from Washington. We could have taken out all 250 of them in about one-and-a-half minutes."

President Ronald Reagan was demanding retaliation, and asked the U.S. Navy and the Joint Chiefs of Staff to draw up target lists, Lehman tells Insight. According to several participants, the Syrian government also had played a role in the plot and several named Syrian officers were suggested as potential targets, as was the Syrian defense ministry.

"It is my recollection that I had been briefed on who had done it and what the evidence was," Lehman says. "I was told the actual names of the Syrians and where they were. I was told about the evidence that the Iranian government was directly behind it. I was told that the people who had done it were trained in Baalbek and that many of them were back in Baalbek. I recall very clearly that there was no controversy who did it. I never heard any briefer or person in the corridor who said, 'Oh maybe we don't know who did it.'"

Insight has learned that, within three weeks of the attack, enough intelligence had been gathered to determine exactly where and how to hit back, and a counterstrike package was briefed directly to the president. Planners say it included eight Tomahawk missiles launched from the battleship New Jersey against the Syrian defense ministry and other command targets in Syria. Carrier-based A6-A Intruders were assigned to bomb the Sheikh Abdallah barracks in Baalbek in a joint strike with the French, who had lost 58 marines when their own barracks, known as the "Drakkar," was bombed just minutes after the U.S. Marines. It also included selected "snatches" of Syrian officers based in Lebanon who had helped carry out the operation.

Coordinates already were being programmed into the Tomahawks, and the A6 pilots and snatch teams were being briefed, say the intelligence and defense officials Insight interviewed, when someone pulled the plug. By all accounts, that someone was Weinberger.

In his memoirs, Weinberger made clear that he had opposed deployment of the Marines to Beirut in the first place because they were never given a clear mission. He also expressed regret - which he repeated in an interview with Insight - that he had not been "persuasive" enough at White House meetings to convince the president to withdraw the Marines before the October 1983 attack occurred. "I was begging the president to take us out of Lebanon," he tells Insight. "We were sitting right in the middle of the bull's-eye."

Weinberger believed the United States should only deploy U.S. troops in situations where "the objectives were so important to American interests that we had to fight," at which point, the United States should commit "enough forces to win and win overwhelmingly." Those conditions were not present in Lebanon in 1983, he argued. But Weinberger was overpowered by secretary of state George Shultz, who argued at the White House meetings that the United States could not afford to give the impression it would "cut and run" after the attack since that would only encourage the terrorists. As it soon did.

Speaking with Insight, Weinberger insists today that the only reason the United States did not retaliate for the October 1983 attack on the U.S. Marines "was the lack of specific knowledge of who the perpetrators were. We had nothing before the bombing, although I had warned repeatedly that the security situation was very bad. We were in the middle of the bull's-eye, but we didn't know who was attacking the bull's-eye."

Weinberger insists that he has "never heard of any specific information. If I had known, I wouldn't have hesitated" to approve retaliatory action. "Clearly the attack was planned. But it was hard to locate who had done it out of all the different groups. The president didn't want some kind of carpet bombing that would kill a lot of innocent civilians. There were so many groups and not all of them were responsible to the government of Iran. All we knew was that they were united in their hatred of America."

Weinberger's account surprised several other participants who had firsthand knowledge of the intelligence information. "Perhaps Weinberger was never given the intercept by his staff," one participant suggested.

At the time highly classified NSA material such as the Damascus intercept would have been given to the chairman of the Joint Chief of Staff, Gen. John Vessey, and to the military aide to the secretary of defense, who would determine whether the secretary would be apprised of the information personally. Weinberger's aide at the time was Maj. Gen. Colin Powell.

But Vessey tells Insight he has "no recollection" of seeing the intelligence on Iran's involvement in the attack. "It is unbelievable to me that someone didn't bring it through the director of the Defense Intelligence Agency up to me and the secretary of defense." Somewhere along the line, the system broke down. "I just don't know what happened," Vessey says. Sources close to Powell suggest the intercept never made it into the president's daily briefing.

On Nov. 16, 1983, Weinberger received a telephone call from Charles Hernu, the French minister of defense, informing him that French Super-Etendard fighter-bombers were getting ready to attack Baalbek. In his memoirs, Weinberger states that he "had received no orders or notifications from the president or anyone prior to that phone call from Paris," which he said gave him too short a notice to scramble U.S. jets.

This reporter was covering the fighting between Arafat and Syrian-backed PLO rebels in Tripoli, Lebanon, at the time, and vividly recalls watching the French planes roar overhead en route to Baalbek. The raid was a total failure.

Whatever the reasons behind the refusal of the United States to join that French retaliatory raid, there can be no doubt that the terrorists and their masters took the U.S. failure to retaliate as a sign of weakness. Just five months later, Iran's top agent in Beirut, Imad Mugniyeh, took CIA station chief William Buckley hostage and hideously tortured him to death after extracting whatever information he could. Since then, notes former Navy secretary Lehman, Osama bin Laden has "directly credited the Marine bombing" and the lack of U.S. retaliation as encouraging his jihadi movement to believe they could attack the United States with impunity.

"The first shots in the war on terror we are in now were fired in Beirut in October 1983," says Geraghty. "The [Bush] administration is now doing exactly what we need to be doing, attacking the enemies of freedom where they live instead of letting them attack us in our home." But the failure to strike back against Iran and Syria in 1983 was a dreadful mistake, he says. "This was an act of war. We knew who the players were. And, because we didn't respond, we emboldened these people to increase the violence."

Never again.

Kenneth R. Timmerman is a senior writer for Insight magazine.

Click here to read the Original story


A Marine 'Peacekeeper's' Story

Posted Dec. 22, 2003

By Kenneth R. Timmerman

Steve Edward Russell, an E-5 sergeant with the 2nd Marine Division out of Camp Lejeune, N.C., was in the guard post directly in front of the lobby when he heard a loud snap, "like a two-by-four breaking" out by the main gate. When he turned to look, he saw a large Mercedes water truck coming through the open gate, leaning heavily as it swerved around barriers. Russell fiddled briefly with his sidearm, but realized it was not loaded - in keeping with the rules of engagement for this "peacekeeping" mission. Then he saw that the truck was coming straight for him.

He made eye contact with the driver - a man in his mid-twenties with curly hair and an olive complexion, wearing what looked like a camouflage shirt - "and the only thing on my mind was to warn." He began running, screaming to Marines who were milling around to get out, but got one last look at the driver. He had "a sh--ty grin, a smile of success you might say." Russell made it to the other side of the building when the truck exploded, wounding him severely.

As he gave his testimony to a courtroom packed with family members of victims, Russell exploded with 20 years of guilt for not having been able to stop the truck. "I hope I've done some good today," he said, "and if I step down right now and drop dead I'd be happy because I've been a good Marine."