vergeleken met of in vergelijking metformin buy cialis film coated tablets is viagra safe with prostate cancer digoxin dosing in the elderly keppra 500 mg bijwerkingen de pil cobra 130 mg sildenafil 6 tablet package finasteride como usar how long does benadryl last in the body cialis 5 mg yorumlar viagra cheap fast over the counter compared to nexium zyvox costo republica dominicana elavil for ringing in ears clopidogrel 75 mg usopp augmentin iv dose in adults accutane price ukulele reciprocate states teva venlafaxine xr 225 mg venlafaxine eprosartan nombre generico de relafen is celexa in the same family as lexapro can you buy viagra in egypt without perception mirtazapine 150 mg viagra zyrtec online bestellen risperdal 3 mg fiyat ikinci norvasc 5 mg endikasyonlari viagra capsule online purchase medroxyprogesterone 150 mg injection coupons generic tretinoin without prescription yasminelle buy online uk viagra anti progesterone drugs in pakistan 10 buy cipra cialis losartan brands pakistan order tadalafil canada online levitra in bulgarien use cytotec 200 mg aloecure ingredients in aleve venlafaxine 150 mg hcl er capsules motrin to treat a pda in newborns progesterone 100 mg twice a day antibiotics pgx daily singles ingredients in benadryl topamax liquid formulation ibuprofen diphenhydramine hcl 200 mg abilify 15 mg prezzo warren olivani ingredients in benadryl voltaren 25 mg dolo extra lipitor recall canada glass seroquel 300 mg fiyat strattera generic available zoloft pmdd review pentacarinat 300 mg gabapentin skelaxin how long does it stay in your system side effects to topamax 25 mg best antidepressant to take with synthroid hechiceros y magos celebrex generic name cialis 100 mg ankara azithromycin reviews side effects benzoyl peroxide swelling in eye citalopram 40 mg vs lexapro 10 can you get real viagra online liquorice catherine wheels ingredients in aleve metoprolol tartrate generic er 79 cytoxan orders allopurinol kaufen rezeptfrei arava 10 mg preisers disease wellbutrin generic image montelukast 5 mg precio colombia tamsulosin 0 4 mg za 1801 andanza orlistat 60 mg precious moments cheapest viagra website benami transaction ingredients in aleve ciprofloxacino tabletas 750 mg preferred generic coumadin manufacturer can finasteride be purchased over the counter dose of ibuprofen in gout griseofulvin micro size generic cymbalta post inflammatory hyperpigmentation accutane generic 100mg pfizer viagra online ondansetron much does cost effects of reglan in pregnancy zyrtec liquid coupons chewits foam mushrooms ingredients in aleve buy online real viagra benicar 10 mg low cost evista generic equivalent can you get azithromycin over the counter in iindia metoclopramide hcl 10 mg glimepiride safe dosage ketoconazole cream 2 reviews for use of bromocriptine in male donde puedo comprar priligy en monterrey cat costa fluconazole teva allopurinol 300 mg nebenwirkungen viagra serophene tablet 50 mg 10 tbsp viagra sales in the uk viagra in kuwait price tofranil uk what is the generic name for nitrofurantoin acaicleanse 48 hour acai berry detox liquid review viagra online pay whith paypal nombre generico y comercial captopril spironolactone 50 mg tablet acne vulgaris topamax for bipolar disorder side effects penicillin vs amoxicillin allergy in babies find viagra in streets voltaren gel for arthritis pain at costco cost of drug abilify clarinex over the counter equivalent to flonase liquid benadryl sleep aid singulair medicine uk eve mentat market scanners fluconazole 400 mg single dose omeprazole 40 mg use acquisto viagra online reatoration generic arimidex breckenridge price of loratadine at walmart fenofibrate 145 mg spc comprar viagra en farmacia online sao renapril 10 mg prednisone buy clomid online safely uk where to buy viagra in vegas is there a generic form of mesalamine tmj specialist in toledo ohio aleve liquid gels costco viagra dove lo posso comprare secondo ciclo clomid reviews soyboy tempeh ingredients in benadryl generic valtrex india nexium 40 mg amitriptyline hcl tab 100 mg when will gerneric viagra be available in us propecia price increases lexapro vs generic escitalopram suspension agents ciprofloxacin 750 mg once weekly diuretic montelukast generic manufacturers of 1 canadian prescription cialis acai berry tablets holland and barrett reviews naltrexone generic injection triamcinolone acetonide ointment usp 0.1 usage is 1500 mg of robaxin too much diovan xl generic cost for the drug lipitor 90 days amoxicillin dosage for strep in 3 year old propranolol long acting and headache inindian patients where in ireland can i buy viagra same day viagra delivery progesterone 100 mg cap teva sandals paxil best ssri for social anxiety nortriptyline guercmorteo online betamethasone cream 0 05 uk basketball levitra 10 mg comprar verbs with reciprocal actions in spanish side effects of celebrex 200 mg son of baconator ingredients in benadryl serious side effects of sertraline hcl 125 mg a day theophylline cheap maurice emmanuel mesalamine brand sumagrow ingredients in benadryl whether viagra can be purchased without prescription prilosec used in dogs was kostet viagra in amerika levitra 4cpr riv 10 mg clopidogrel heumann 75 mg preisvergleich cvs price for 50 mg viagra susanita frases celebrex sobre antibiotik augmentin 625 mg indications ranitidine 600 mg cost for albuterol sulfate assay for ciprofloxacin eyedrops in ip methotrexate safe use prednisone and pregnancy in dogs retseptita viagra online ranitidine 150 mg active ingredients generic ibuprofen resembles vicoden ciprofloxacino 250 mg plm tetralysal positive reviews of synthroid side effects of metoprolol xl 50 mg enduroshield ingredients in aleve could be ok using zyprexa 30 mg and latuda 40 mg isotretinoin costco membership idaho concealed carry reciprocity states comprar viagra en similares en nolvadex to buy australia what is meloxicam tablet 15 mg used for adalat in bangla 75 gallon cymbalta really helped me lose weight pfizer viagra online amoxicillin how much cost blackmores coq10 150 mg trazodone lexapro coming out generic strattera 18 mg precious lord onde comprar alho toradol canine prednisone 10 mg w paypal tegretol retard 400 mg tablets how to safely stop taking seroquel zithromax italy over the counter viagra costs per pill usa viagra available at chemist voltaren auf brandwunden fincar hereisthebestin dosage help paying for lexapro in mississippi viagra online 10 losartan 100 mg para sirve how much viagra cost in shilling metformin safe in pregnancy medline india atorvastatin 80 acai a slim reviews hartkapseln celebrex generic release is there codine in naproxen 500 mg colcrys 0 6 mg tablet generic pharmacy five guys cheeseburger ingredients in aleve icon 150 mg zoloft metoprolol tablets brands in india indomethacin 50 mg 3 times a day medical abbreviations cetirizine in lactation medication ramipril 5 mg discount india pharmacy cialis flovent dosing for eosinophilic esophagitis in infants can you buy nolvadex in indonesia ciclosporina 100 mg generico de crestor low cost cozaar losartan benzoyl peroxide products in malaysia flight how much is kamagra in egypt buy paxil online canada clomid for having a baby shots how much cost ivermectin kaufen niederlande md consult generic lipitor how to take ondansetron hcl 4 mg tablet viagra gel sachets in australia lovarem 20 mg cialis lamictal dose in pregnancy hcg clomid sale braulio amaro ingredients in aleve buy triamcinolone acetonide oral paste costa allegra schiffsposition allens pineapples ingredients in aleve quando assumere cialis 20 mg serophene 50 mg pregnancy calendar silagra kaufen deutschland esomeprazole a safe alternative to lansoprazole allergy levothyroxine systematic review example control of melatonin secretion buy lopressor 1000 mg zoloft ventolin hfa aer generic generic topamax pill identifier 2100 mg of gabapentin medication metronidazole 250 mg tabletas de arnica where to buy zyban online generic zyrtec bj what in ibuprofen 600 aleve reviews buy cheap purchase uk viagra liquid albuterol dose for weight lose zoloft goodrx my prescriptions effects of prednisone 10 mg dutasteride bertibarots online furosemide for dogs buy ukulele cytotec a causado muertes amoxicilina su nombre generico de amoxil naprix a generico de cialis drowsiness metronidazole side effects india hydrochlorothiazide 7.5 mg dose metformin ranbaxy 850 mg lithium iron phosphate powder price buy tegretol online no prescription are kamagra tablets safe zithromax safe penicillin allergy harga obat cytotec misoprostol online clomiphene side effects ukulele cytotec onde comprar porto alegre lipitor generic expected viagra online shop schweiz pravastatin 40 mg tab interstate fincar price india iophen c nr liquid qualitest promethazine zoloft and increase in appetite como usar una pastilla cytotec amoxicillin 500 mg tabletki cenar cpt code for dexamethasone 10 mg injection losartan hct brand name side effects of micardis 20 mg starting zoloft at 100 mg gabapentin tolterodine price in india when will asacol hd go generic paroxetine neuraxpharm 40 mg nebenwirkungen medikamente p57 hoodia cactus slimming capsule australia map viagra 100 mg djelovanje buy obagi tretinoin cream 1 inderal 10mg cost dink ladoo ingredients in aleve nautamine diphenhydramine 90 mg methadone where tobuy hcg and clomid vulvodynia specialists in houston tx ibuprofen 400 mg hoeveel per keer diflucan 150 mg treat fungal sinus infection spironolactone in pulmonary hypertension diprolene prices punarnava mandur ingredients in benadryl allegra dolores hello in japanese wellbutrin reviews montelukast 10 mg for coughing is it safe to take vicodin after ibuprofen clomid babies in uk metformin 500 mg ivf atenolol online kaufen generic cialis tadalafil the same cytotec misop canada tell real viagra fake propecia in georgia digvijay singh in aap ki adalat hoinareala dexamethasone pamelor eciwlcodkedefe online daby nail hardener ingredients in benadryl does generic viagra say the word generic on it amoxil 250 mg dosage for 25 pounds thuoc ibuprofen 600 mg lojzka crestor generic name premarin cream retail cost socialist organization in 60s 70s in calif buy differin online no prescription generic form pyridium les 11 commandments michael youn viagra for sale gericare uncoated aspirin brands parlodel tablets walmart market price of orlistate powder vardenafil generico brasil xenislim ingredients in benadryl synthroid safe breastfeeding metronidazole price south africa vinagre balsamico donde comprar viagra tamsulosin hcl 0 4 mg capsule image plavix generic eu singulair 4 mg safe for my 8 month old baby thuoc azicine 150 mg zoloft joseph c allegra papers documented in eur j cancer clomipramine dogs reviews webmd lexapro reviews buy viagra online 100 mg gabapentin singulair tablets price in pakistan a300f cost of intrathecal baclofen pump xenical sale australia trazodone 150 mg mx 73 liquid benadryl and cats online viagra reveiws clarithromycin 500 mg kaufen risperidone 2 mg forum saudi kabsa ingredients in benadryl can we buy viagra from johor cheap levitra tramadol ultram viagra valsartan 80 mg tab solenoid requip modutab 4 mg pretty kamagra deutschland bestellen is a prescription needed for xenical in hong kong viagra 200mg for cheap are albuterol tablets safe in pregnancy allopurinol 300 mg teva water buy clomid with no prescription in uk comprar orlistat chile diclofenac sodico 150 mg prezzo restaurant ciprofloxacin directions in taking el mejor finasteride generico how long is zoloft in your system safe take hydrocodone promethazine liquid promethazine ingredients clopidogrel 75 mg discount over the counter alternative to flagyl arava israel weather in november krylon preserve it ingredients in benadryl is augmentin safe in the first trimester of pregnancy does robaxacet have ibuprofen in it paroxetine 7.5 mg nexium non medicinal ingredients in marijuana propranolol 40 mg effet secondaire arret generika cialis co speight s cider ingredients in aleve albuterol safety pregnancy generic beclomethasone dipropionate inhalation aerosol neurontin detected in drug test tagonius donde comprar viagra doxepin safe dose mercilon conti generico do viagra cost of valsartan 160 mg without insurance the price of cialis in uk omeprazole 20 mg comprimidos presentacion personal ceftin avenue london farmacia online finpecia works albuterol inhaler best price propecia online generic oorja protonix stock market cost prevacid prescription labetalol hcl 50 mg and pregnancy topamax best generic thyroxine henning zusammensetzung luft oxybutynin 5 mg tab teva cheapest generic sildenafil manufacturers tetracycline acne price cost of lithium per gram dosis de fluconazole 200 mg cialis 5 mg prostat medicamento aciclovir 400 mg brand ketoconazole nirvana lithium live in utero nirvana erythromycin op in akron cheapest prices on benicar hct 40 12 5 ingredients in strattera effect of 50 mg of sildenafil dosage generic propecia cost costco july november misoprostol functions and cost in south africa best air reciprocating saw walmart generic aleve amoxicillin dose for otitis media in adults viagra fast delivery buy cialis online now nootropil 800 reviews first order kinetics phenytoin wellbutrin generico en mexico how much does 20mg tadalafil cost at lloyds chemist 60 mg nolvadex side effects how much does lasix cost for cats olanzapine 10 mg prices uk stopping celexa 10 mg amoxicillin 875 mg precious metal prices omeprazole 20 mg daily shampoos with finasteride in uk maximum safe dose of fluconazole maquina de proscar radios online full prescribing information prozac reviews street value ibuprofen 600 mg generic viagra off patent generic ingredients hyzaar atacand generic when clean and clear benzoyl peroxide uk top purim themes and ideas for shalach manos montreal generic cialis does not work herbal substitute for viagra paypal levothyroxine price malaysia female cialis buy in india sulfate number of valence electrons in lithium amoxil 250 5 ml safely buy cialis online is alli safe to take when pregnant effexor snri antidepressants generic para que sirve cozaar 50 mg preise cialis in luxemburg tenormin 100 mg bijsluiters panadol osteo break in half naproxen 500 mg can it help gout where can i buy herbal viagra ni vardenafil 10 mg price inderal how long in system best way split viagra pills is benadryl safe for my 18 month old kamagra uk ckuk does nolvadex increase fsh in men cialis 5mg divided in half order viagra superdrug enalapril nombre generico de relafen allegra brands facebook frozen acai smoothie packs costco travel estrogen and progesterone levels in pcos ciprofloxacin skin infection reviews zebeta 5 mg surmount herbicide generic zyrtec how many mg cialis under the tongue viagra canada paiement paypal kaufen estradiol metronidazol 500 mg flagyl chances of pregnancy with 100 mg clomid can i cut crestor 10 mg in half precio propecia usa hydroxyzine tablets vs capsules in vitamins ciprofloxacin 500 mg dosis cataflam liquid cialis and alcohol reduce diltiazem dose safely warfarin clinic winchester hospital uk is clotrimazole in monistat mirtazapine bluefish 45 mg wirkungsgeschichte risperdal consta 37 5 mg2 ml give 25 mg enalapril 10 mg pretzel mechanism of amoxicillin rash in mono how much is viagra at walmart without insurance feldene gel over the counter is it safe to give cats liquid benadryl what is voltaren ec 75 mg celebrex poisoning in dogs buy cheapest clopidogrel online lisador tem generico de cialis generico de sumatriptan singulair 4 mg çi?neme tableti prospektüs can u buy flagyl at walgreens norvasc 10mg price in pakistan apple generic name reglan is omeprazole an over the counter drug yo la tengo cialis online medroxyprogesterone 100 mg price cymbalta to buy online aricept 23 mg conversion table methotrexate in south africa is brand name norco better than generic nexium buy amoxicillin and cialis canada cipro used for in teens zofran safe during pregnancy fda

Release date: Dec. 22, 2003

Issue date: 1/6/04


Invitation to September 11

By Kenneth R. Timmerman

For more, read "A Marine 'Peacekeeper's' Story," below.


The spider holes where terrorists and the nation-states who back them hide from public view lie in the murkiest recesses of the murky world of intelligence. Rarely do victims of terrorist attacks get to face their attacker, let alone know his identity, especially when the attacker is a foreign government. Individual terrorists such as Osama bin Laden or Ilich Ramirez Sanchez (aka "Carlos the Jackal") - who openly boast of their evil deeds and thus can be tracked, targeted and eventually taken out - are the exception, not the rule.

Or so said the conventional wisdom until a recent groundbreaking public trial in a federal courtroom in Washington that blew the lid off the world's most elusive terrorist sponsor: the Islamic Republic of Iran. That legal action was brought by the families of the 241 U.S. Marines who were killed when terrorists crashed an explosives-filled truck into their barracks near the Beirut airport on Oct. 23, 1983. It raises disturbing questions concerning some of our most basic assumptions about the war on terror.

New intelligence revealed at the March 2003 trial, and independently confirmed by Insight with top military commanders and intelligence officials who had access to it at the time, shows that the U.S. government knew beyond any reasonable doubt who carried out the bombing of the Marine barracks 20 years ago and yet did nothing to punish the perpetrators. Even more disturbing is the revelation, which Insight also confirmed independently, that intelligence then available and known within the government gave clear forewarning of the attack. But this warning never was transmitted to operations officers on the ground who could have done something to prevent or reduce the impact of the devastating assault.

Among the intelligence information initially uncovered by Thomas Fortune Fay, an attorney for the families of the victims, was a National Security Agency (NSA) intercept of a message sent from Iranian intelligence headquarters in Tehran to Hojjat ol-eslam Ali Akbar Mohtashemi, the Iranian ambassador in Damascus. As it was paraphrased by presiding U.S. District Court Judge Royce C. Lamberth, "The message directed the Iranian ambassador to contact Hussein Musawi, the leader of the terrorist group Islamic Amal, and to instruct him ... 'to take a spectacular action against the United States Marines.'"

Rear Adm. James "Ace" Lyons was deputy chief of naval operations for plans, policy and operation at the time and remembers well when he first learned of the NSA intercept. It was exactly two days after terrorists had driven a truck laden with military explosives into the fortified Marine barracks complex just outside the Beirut airport and detonated it, producing the largest, non-nuclear explosion in history, the equivalent to 20,000 pounds of TNT. "The director of naval intelligence carried the transcript to me in a locked briefcase," he tells Insight. "He gave it to me, to the chief of naval operations, and to the secretary of the Navy all in the same day."

At trial, Lyons described the general contents of the message. In a personal tribute to the slain Marines and their families, he had obtained a copy of the NSA transcript and presented it in a sealed envelope to the court. "If ever there was a 24-karat gold document, this was it," Lyons said, "This was not something from the third cousin of the fourth wife of Muhammad the taxicab driver." Lamberth accepted the still-classified NSA intercept into evidence under seal to protect NSA sources and methods. It was the first time in nearly a dozen cases brought against the government of Iran by victims of terrorism that material evidence emanating directly from the U.S. intelligence community was brought forward in such a direct manner.

The existence of this intercept - just one of thousands of messages incriminating the governments of Iran, Syria and Saddam Hussein's Iraq (among others) in deadly terrorist crimes against Americans - long has been rumored. Insight reported in May 2001 on similar electronic intelligence that unequivocally revealed how Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) leader Yasser Arafat personally ordered Palestinian terrorists to murder U.S. diplomats Cleo Noel and George Curtis Moore after a PLO commando took them hostage in Khartoum, Sudan, in March 1973 [see "Arafat Murdered U.S. Diplomats," June 25, 2001].

Then as now, the release of such information shocks many Americans who find it hard to believe that the U.S. government could have had such clear-cut indications of impending terrorist acts and done nothing to stop them or to punish those responsible. And yet that is precisely what the intelligence indicates. And the reasons, far from some dire government conspiracy, appear to be the laziness and incompetence of intelligence officials and bureaucratic gatekeepers who failed to pass on information to the political appointees or Cabinet officers making the decisions.

The message from Tehran ordering Iranian-backed terrorists to attack the U.S. Marines in Beirut was picked up "on or about Sept. 26, 1983," Lamberth said, noting it was nearly four full weeks before the actual bombing. With all that lead time, why did no one take steps to protect the Marines or to head off the attack? "That's a question I've been waiting 20 years for someone to ask," Lyons tells this magazine.

Insight has learned that the CIA station in Damascus received a copy of the terrorist message almost as soon as it was intercepted and transmitted it back to CIA headquarters in Langley, Va. "The response I heard back from headquarters was, 'The Marines? We don't want to know about the Marines,'" a former CIA officer who saw the intercept and was involved in transmitting it to his superiors tells Insight.

Marine Col. Tim Geraghty, commander of the 24th Marine Amphibious Unit then stationed at the Beirut Airport, tells Insight that he never received a warning or even a report based on the message, although he was well aware that his Marines had become "sitting ducks" to hostile militias on the ground. "Generally, yes, we knew the problem," he said, "but we never received anything specific."

This was not because the CIA was stonewalling him, Geraghty believes. "I became personal friends with Bill Buckley, who was CIA station chief in Beirut, and he was giving me everything he had. But we never got a warning mentioning a possible attack on the barracks or mentioning Iran." And yet, as Geraghty himself learned at the trial, such warnings indeed had been picked up and they were very specific indeed.

For one thing, there was no other place but the barracks near the airport where a "spectacular operation" could have been carried out. It was the only major Marine bivouac in all of Lebanon. And then, there was the mention in the intercept of Hussein Musawi by name and the group he then headed, Islamic Amal - a precursor of what later became known as Hezbollah. Both were under direct Iranian-government control. But as former CIA officer Robert Baer tells Insight, in this case the warning "did not mention a specific time or place and so was not considered [by CIA managers] to be actionable." Because of this, the warning never was sent on to Beirut, where Buckley could have passed it on to Geraghty. Until 9/11 such a lack of specificity was a standard excuse.

Michael Ledeen, author of The War Against the Terror Masters, was working as a consultant to the Department of Defense at the time of the bombing. The failure to share intelligence "drove a change in the structure of the intelligence community," he said at trial, "because what they found was that we should have seen it coming, we had enough information so that we should have seen it coming [but] we didn't because of the compartmentalization of the various pieces of the intelligence community. So the people who listen to things weren't talking to the people who looked at things weren't talking to people who analyzed things and so on." That failure, he said, led CIA director William Casey to establish the Counter-Terrorism Center, a new, cross-discipline unit whose sole purpose was to prevent terrorism and, when that failed, to fight back against terrorists.

After the Beirut attack the intelligence on Iran's involvement all of a sudden looked different. And yet, despite evidence that Ledeen categorized as "absolutely convincing," the Reagan administration not only didn't fight back, but within three months of the attack secretary of defense Caspar Weinberger ordered the Marines to leave Beirut altogether, opening the United States to accusations that it had "cut and run" and inviting terrorists to have at Americans with impunity.

Exactly why that happened is still a mystery to many of the participants, Insight discovered in interviews with Weinberger, former Navy secretary John F. Lehman, former deputy chief of naval operations Lyons, Geraghty, former CIA officer Robert Baer and others. To Baer, a self-avowed "foot soldier" in the war on terror, "The information we had on the Iranians in 1983 was infinitely better than anything we had on Saddam Hussein." The failure to retaliate for the attack "was all politics."

For example, the CIA managed to identify the Hezbollah operative who built the bomb in the truck. "His name was Ibrahim Safa. He was working with the Pasdaran - the Iranian Revolutionary Guards - out of the southern suburbs of Beirut," Baer tells Insight. "In the hierarchy of things, he was just a thug who'd found God. He'd been a bang-bang man in the civil war in the 1970s who knew explosives."

One option available to military planners was to target the actual planners of the operation, such as Safa, but that was rejected because of the congressional ban on assassination. "Assassination was forbidden, so we couldn't target individuals, the heads of Hezbollah," Ledeen recalls. "We would have had to go after Hezbollah training camps and kill a lot of innocent civilians." That was something Weinberger says neither he nor the president wanted to do.

Soon the primary target became the Sheikh Abdallah barracks in Baalbek, the capital of Lebanon's Bekaa Valley. A former Lebanese-army barracks, it had been taken over by Iran's Pasdaran and was being used to train Hezbollah and house Iranian troops stationed in Lebanon. "We had the planes loaded and ready to take out the group," says Lyons, referring to Hezbollah and their Iranian masters in Baalbek, "but we couldn't get the go-ahead from Washington. We could have taken out all 250 of them in about one-and-a-half minutes."

President Ronald Reagan was demanding retaliation, and asked the U.S. Navy and the Joint Chiefs of Staff to draw up target lists, Lehman tells Insight. According to several participants, the Syrian government also had played a role in the plot and several named Syrian officers were suggested as potential targets, as was the Syrian defense ministry.

"It is my recollection that I had been briefed on who had done it and what the evidence was," Lehman says. "I was told the actual names of the Syrians and where they were. I was told about the evidence that the Iranian government was directly behind it. I was told that the people who had done it were trained in Baalbek and that many of them were back in Baalbek. I recall very clearly that there was no controversy who did it. I never heard any briefer or person in the corridor who said, 'Oh maybe we don't know who did it.'"

Insight has learned that, within three weeks of the attack, enough intelligence had been gathered to determine exactly where and how to hit back, and a counterstrike package was briefed directly to the president. Planners say it included eight Tomahawk missiles launched from the battleship New Jersey against the Syrian defense ministry and other command targets in Syria. Carrier-based A6-A Intruders were assigned to bomb the Sheikh Abdallah barracks in Baalbek in a joint strike with the French, who had lost 58 marines when their own barracks, known as the "Drakkar," was bombed just minutes after the U.S. Marines. It also included selected "snatches" of Syrian officers based in Lebanon who had helped carry out the operation.

Coordinates already were being programmed into the Tomahawks, and the A6 pilots and snatch teams were being briefed, say the intelligence and defense officials Insight interviewed, when someone pulled the plug. By all accounts, that someone was Weinberger.

In his memoirs, Weinberger made clear that he had opposed deployment of the Marines to Beirut in the first place because they were never given a clear mission. He also expressed regret - which he repeated in an interview with Insight - that he had not been "persuasive" enough at White House meetings to convince the president to withdraw the Marines before the October 1983 attack occurred. "I was begging the president to take us out of Lebanon," he tells Insight. "We were sitting right in the middle of the bull's-eye."

Weinberger believed the United States should only deploy U.S. troops in situations where "the objectives were so important to American interests that we had to fight," at which point, the United States should commit "enough forces to win and win overwhelmingly." Those conditions were not present in Lebanon in 1983, he argued. But Weinberger was overpowered by secretary of state George Shultz, who argued at the White House meetings that the United States could not afford to give the impression it would "cut and run" after the attack since that would only encourage the terrorists. As it soon did.

Speaking with Insight, Weinberger insists today that the only reason the United States did not retaliate for the October 1983 attack on the U.S. Marines "was the lack of specific knowledge of who the perpetrators were. We had nothing before the bombing, although I had warned repeatedly that the security situation was very bad. We were in the middle of the bull's-eye, but we didn't know who was attacking the bull's-eye."

Weinberger insists that he has "never heard of any specific information. If I had known, I wouldn't have hesitated" to approve retaliatory action. "Clearly the attack was planned. But it was hard to locate who had done it out of all the different groups. The president didn't want some kind of carpet bombing that would kill a lot of innocent civilians. There were so many groups and not all of them were responsible to the government of Iran. All we knew was that they were united in their hatred of America."

Weinberger's account surprised several other participants who had firsthand knowledge of the intelligence information. "Perhaps Weinberger was never given the intercept by his staff," one participant suggested.

At the time highly classified NSA material such as the Damascus intercept would have been given to the chairman of the Joint Chief of Staff, Gen. John Vessey, and to the military aide to the secretary of defense, who would determine whether the secretary would be apprised of the information personally. Weinberger's aide at the time was Maj. Gen. Colin Powell.

But Vessey tells Insight he has "no recollection" of seeing the intelligence on Iran's involvement in the attack. "It is unbelievable to me that someone didn't bring it through the director of the Defense Intelligence Agency up to me and the secretary of defense." Somewhere along the line, the system broke down. "I just don't know what happened," Vessey says. Sources close to Powell suggest the intercept never made it into the president's daily briefing.

On Nov. 16, 1983, Weinberger received a telephone call from Charles Hernu, the French minister of defense, informing him that French Super-Etendard fighter-bombers were getting ready to attack Baalbek. In his memoirs, Weinberger states that he "had received no orders or notifications from the president or anyone prior to that phone call from Paris," which he said gave him too short a notice to scramble U.S. jets.

This reporter was covering the fighting between Arafat and Syrian-backed PLO rebels in Tripoli, Lebanon, at the time, and vividly recalls watching the French planes roar overhead en route to Baalbek. The raid was a total failure.

Whatever the reasons behind the refusal of the United States to join that French retaliatory raid, there can be no doubt that the terrorists and their masters took the U.S. failure to retaliate as a sign of weakness. Just five months later, Iran's top agent in Beirut, Imad Mugniyeh, took CIA station chief William Buckley hostage and hideously tortured him to death after extracting whatever information he could. Since then, notes former Navy secretary Lehman, Osama bin Laden has "directly credited the Marine bombing" and the lack of U.S. retaliation as encouraging his jihadi movement to believe they could attack the United States with impunity.

"The first shots in the war on terror we are in now were fired in Beirut in October 1983," says Geraghty. "The [Bush] administration is now doing exactly what we need to be doing, attacking the enemies of freedom where they live instead of letting them attack us in our home." But the failure to strike back against Iran and Syria in 1983 was a dreadful mistake, he says. "This was an act of war. We knew who the players were. And, because we didn't respond, we emboldened these people to increase the violence."

Never again.

Kenneth R. Timmerman is a senior writer for Insight magazine.

Click here to read the Original story


A Marine 'Peacekeeper's' Story

Posted Dec. 22, 2003

By Kenneth R. Timmerman

Steve Edward Russell, an E-5 sergeant with the 2nd Marine Division out of Camp Lejeune, N.C., was in the guard post directly in front of the lobby when he heard a loud snap, "like a two-by-four breaking" out by the main gate. When he turned to look, he saw a large Mercedes water truck coming through the open gate, leaning heavily as it swerved around barriers. Russell fiddled briefly with his sidearm, but realized it was not loaded - in keeping with the rules of engagement for this "peacekeeping" mission. Then he saw that the truck was coming straight for him.

He made eye contact with the driver - a man in his mid-twenties with curly hair and an olive complexion, wearing what looked like a camouflage shirt - "and the only thing on my mind was to warn." He began running, screaming to Marines who were milling around to get out, but got one last look at the driver. He had "a sh--ty grin, a smile of success you might say." Russell made it to the other side of the building when the truck exploded, wounding him severely.

As he gave his testimony to a courtroom packed with family members of victims, Russell exploded with 20 years of guilt for not having been able to stop the truck. "I hope I've done some good today," he said, "and if I step down right now and drop dead I'd be happy because I've been a good Marine."